Understanding Spreads: ECN vs. Dealing Desk
Before diving into the direct comparison, it's essential to understand the underlying models that influence spreads. IC Markets primarily operates with an ECN (Electronic Communication Network) model, which aims to provide raw spreads directly from liquidity providers, often supplemented by a commission per lot. XM, on the other hand, typically employs a market maker or dealing desk model, where spreads can be wider but are often commission-free.
This fundamental difference impacts not just the numerical spread values but also the execution speed, potential for re-quotes, and overall trading experience. ECN models are often favoured by high-frequency traders and those employing expert advisors due to their emphasis on tight spreads and fast execution. Market maker models can be simpler for beginners, with all-inclusive spreads and predictable pricing.
Spread Comparison: Key Instruments
Both IC Markets and XM offer a vast array of instruments, but for forex traders, the major currency pairs and key commodities are often the primary focus. Here, we'll look at typical spreads for EUR/USD, GBP/USD, and XAU/USD (Gold).
EUR/USD Spreads
The EUR/USD pair is the most liquid in the forex market, and thus, often features the tightest spreads. IC Markets, with its Raw Spread account, can offer spreads as low as 0.0 pips, plus commission. XM's Standard account typically starts from 0.6 pips, with no commission. For high-volume traders, the ECN model with commission can often result in lower overall costs on EUR/USD.
GBP/USD Spreads
The GBP/USD, or 'Cable', is another popular major. Similar to EUR/USD, IC Markets generally provides tighter raw spreads, again with a commission. XM's commission-free spreads for GBP/USD will be wider but might appeal to those who prefer simpler pricing without separate commission calculations. The choice here often depends on your trading frequency and position sizing.
XAU/USD (Gold) Spreads
Trading gold (XAU/USD) is popular for its volatility and safe-haven appeal. Spreads on commodities are generally wider than major forex pairs. IC Markets typically offers competitive raw spreads for gold, alongside its standard commission. XM's spreads on XAU/USD will also be variable but are presented without an additional commission, fitting their market-maker model. Traders of precious metals should always compare the total cost, including any swaps or rollover fees.
Regulatory Landscape and Security
For UK traders, robust regulation is paramount. Both IC Markets and XM operate under various regulatory bodies globally. IC Markets is regulated by ASIC (Australia), CySEC (Cyprus), and SCB (Bahamas). XM also holds licenses from CySEC (Cyprus), ASIC (Australia), IFSC (Belize), and the DFSA (Dubai). It's crucial for UK residents to ensure they are trading with an entity regulated by the FCA, or an equivalent body providing similar client protections.
Trading Platforms
Both brokers offer the industry-standard MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) platforms, which are highly regarded for their charting tools, analytical capabilities, and support for automated trading (Expert Advisors). IC Markets also offers cTrader, a platform highly valued by ECN traders for its advanced order types, depth of market, and sophisticated analytical tools. XM also provides its own XM WebTrader. The availability of cTrader from IC Markets can be a significant differentiator for experienced traders.
Customer Support and Educational Resources
Both brokers offer multilingual customer support, typically available 24/5. They also provide various educational resources, including webinars, tutorials, and market analysis, to help traders improve their skills and stay informed about market developments. The quality and depth of these resources can vary, so it's worth exploring them based on your learning preferences.
Our Verdict by Trader Type
* For Scalpers & High-Frequency Traders: IC Markets, with its ECN model, raw spreads, and cTrader platform, is generally more attractive for those who rely on ultra-tight spreads and fast execution, despite the commission. The overall cost can be lower for high-volume traders.
* For Beginners & Casual Traders: XM, with its commission-free trading accounts and simpler spread-only pricing, might be more appealing. The absence of separate commissions can make cost calculation straightforward, though spreads are comparatively wider.
* For Automated Traders (EAs): Both brokers offer MT4/MT5, which are excellent for Expert Advisors. However, the ECN environment of IC Markets might offer slightly better conditions for EAs that are sensitive to spread fluctuations and execution speed.
* For UK Traders prioritising Regulation: Both brokers are well-regulated in various jurisdictions. Always verify the specific entity you are signing up with and its regulatory oversight for your region.
---
Comparison Table: IC Markets vs XM
| Feature | IC Markets | XM |
| :------------------- | :--------------------------------------- | :------------------------------------- |
| Spreads (EUR/USD) | From 0.0 pips (Raw) | From 0.6 pips (Standard) |
| Spreads (GBP/USD) | From 0.0 pips (Raw) | From 0.9 pips (Standard) |
| Spreads (XAU/USD) | From 0.1 pips (Raw) | From 2.0 pips (Standard) |
| Commission | ~$3.50 per side per lot (Raw Account) | None (Standard Account) |
| Min. Deposit | $200 (or equivalent) | $5 (or equivalent) |
| Regulators | ASIC, CySEC, SCB | CySEC, ASIC, IFSC, DFSA |
| Platforms | MT4, MT5, cTrader | MT4, MT5, XM WebTrader |
*Figures are typical, at time of writing — check broker site for live pricing.*
---
Our Featured Partner: Vantage
While IC Markets and XM offer strong propositions, we also recommend considering Vantage for your trading needs. Vantage is a multi-asset broker providing competitive pricing, robust platforms, and excellent support. For UK traders looking for another reliable option, Vantage offers a compelling alternative. You can learn more and Open a Vantage account.
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.